Athlete and Sports-Related Endorsements
We examine how endorsements and sponsorships work, some key contractual provisions, and showcase some important sponsored athletes worldwide.
We examine how endorsements and sponsorships work, some key contractual provisions, and showcase some important sponsored athletes worldwide.
We examine how endorsements and sponsorships work, some key contractual provisions, and showcase some important sponsored athletes worldwide.
Athletes and Sports-Related Endorsements
We spoke to two experts to help us understand endorsements and sponsorships. Nicholas Hawkins is an Associate Attorney at Womble Bond Dickinson, LLP in Baltimore, Maryland. As a lawyer, he advises companies and entrepreneurs on their intellectual property, brand management, and protection strategies. He also works on mergers and acquisitions, private equity and venture capital financing, and general corporate governance. He also has experience advising celebrities, athletes, and influencers on compliance with the Federal Trade Commission’s guidelines relating to endorsements and advertisements. Nick previously was an in-house lawyer at Under Armour.
Eli Lewis is a YouTuber with 1.5 million subscribers, and a YouTube channel named kaykayes. For reaching 1 million subscribers, YouTube awarded Eli with the Gold Creator Award, a phenomenal achievement. His videos consist of Eli playing Esports including Madden. The topics of his Madden series consist of constant upgrades of the video game which introduces updated stats from individual players. In the virtual world of video games, game players build their teams and have access to limited items such as legendary players and current players. In Eli’s video, “Golden Ticket Michael Vick Is A Cheat Code!,” he had access to legendary NFL player Michael Vick who he used in the competition of Ultimate Team which allows gamers to build their own team and compete with other gamers.
Right to Publicity/Endorsements
Under the law, the right to publicity is an individual’s right to control and limit the commercial use of their name, image, and likeness. Endorsement agreements concern the right to publicity. It allows one party to pay for permission to use the other party’s name, image, and likeness, and benefit from that party’s reputation to market products and services. For example, the rise of influencers has allowed them to be paid by companies for permission to use their name, image, and likeness in advertisements due to their popularity and reach, such as in this ad with Eli: https://www.instagram.com/p/Bey1O9plYgj/?next=%2F
Eli's YouTube channel makes money by running ads on his videos via the YouTube ad sense system. He is also signed with a management team that helps him seek out endorsements. Eli described his process of choosing who to work with as an influencer:
Athletes
Companies and brands often pay famous athletes for permission to use their names, images, and likenesses when advertising products, typically through commercials or the athletes’ social media accounts, where they have a huge fan following.
Here are some examples of famous athletes who are top endorsers, like Virat Kohli (cricketer), LeBron James (NBA), Tom Brady (NFL), and Cristiano Ronaldo (soccer), with their top endorsements and their followers on social media:
Virat Kohli is one of the greatest cricketers in cricket history, the former captain of the Indian national team, and one of the most famous athletes in the world. Kohli has 226 million followers* on Instagram, which is the highest number of followers for a cricketer. Due to his fame and popularity, he earns over $20 million annually through endorsements and sponsorships with Audi, Hero, MRF, Puma, and more. https://www.instagram.com/reel/Clc62_igrpK/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y%3D
LeBron James is one of the greatest basketball players in NBA history, with four NBA championship titles. Labron has 138 million Instagram followers*, which is the highest fan following on Instagram for NBA players. James has a long list of endorsement deals, which help him to earn an estimated $96 million per year on top of his salary. LeBron’s major endorsement deal is with Nike, which is a $1 billion lifetime sponsorship deal. Other endorsements include 2K Sports, AT&T, Beats Electronic, Coca-Cola, McDonalds, and GMC. https://www.instagram.com/p/CdJJF4buEwM/
Tom Brady is the winningest quarterback in history with seven Superbowl rings and 15 Pro Bowl selections. Although Brady has 12.9 million followers* on Instagram, which is fewer compared to other players, he still has a long list of endorsements that reportedly earned him $76 million per year. One of the biggest deals is with Aston Martin, and part of the deal even included a special edition Aston Martin Vanquish S for Brady. Other endorsement deals include Under Armour, TAG Heuer, UGG, Christopher Cloos, and Swiss watch company IWC Schaffhausen.
Cristiano Ronaldo is one of the best soccer players in the current generation and has the most Instagram followers in the world with 512 million*. He is one of the highest-paid athletes for sponsorships and endorsements, which earns him an estimated $120 million per year. Ronaldo is the third athlete to be sponsored by Nike with a $1 billion dollar lifetime deal, after Michael Jordan and LeBron James. His other endorsement deals include Herbalife, Louis Vuitton, and Jacob & Co. https://www.instagram.com/p/ClRVn4wtbIc/
Endorsement Contract Clauses
Athlete endorsement contracts vary, depending on the company, how famous the athlete is, etc. But the following are some of the key provisions typically included in athlete endorsement contracts:
1. ENDORSER'S EVALUATION OF PRODUCTS
Endorsement contracts typically include a clause like the following that gives the endorser the opportunity to use and evaluate products:
“Endorser will conduct such evaluations and use as Endorser reasonably believes necessary to be satisfied that the Products are worthy of Endorser's use and recommendation. Company will provide Endorser [at no charge/at a reduced charge], with [a reasonable quantity or number] of Products for Endorser's own use so that Endorser has the opportunity to meet its obligations under this Agreement.”
In this provision, the company agrees to provide the endorser with sample products that the endorser may use to determine if the products are worthy of his or her endorsement and recommendation. This also gives the endorser the chance to determine if he or she wants to associate his/her brand with it. For example, Cristiano Ronaldo's sponsorship with Jacob & Co. suggests that he was likely provided the watch for free to use on his Instagram page for promotional purposes. It is important to note that this agreement is incentivized therefore can create biased views. With the example provided, Cristiano Ronaldo is paid by Jacob & Co. to promote their product based on his experience, yet his opinion may be biased because he is getting paid. We asked Nick Hawkins about this type of provision.
2. EXCLUSIVE USE OF THE PRODUCTS
Endorsement contracts often include a clause that prohibits endorsers from endorsing competitive products:
“To facilitate and enhance the Company's use of the Endorsement, the Endorser shall:
1. Use Products Exclusively and not Competitive/Competitors' products or services;
2. Make affirmative efforts to be seen using the Products when: (A) Appearing [in/on] [PUBLIC VENUE RELATING TO ENDORSER'S RENOWN]; (B) Participating in promotional activities in any media, including but not limited to a website, blog, tweet, or other social media; (C) Taking part in photoshoots; or (D) Otherwise appearing in public.
3. Use [his/her] best efforts to promote the sale and use of the Products and promote the relationship between Endorser and Company.”
This provision includes the obligation for the endorser to only use the companies' products and not the products of competitors. When making public appearances, the endorser is expected to show off the sponsored products virtually or in person. This includes endorsers engaging in social media and partaking in photoshoots to advertise the product. All these efforts are to expose the company's brand by using the influence of the endorser. When an athlete is sponsored by a company and promotes a competitor's product, it can negatively affect the company. This can cause a loss in profit for the company and negatively affect its brand.
In our interview with Nick, he mentioned that companies approach the negotiation by seeking broad rights in the contract while the endorsers will approach the negotiation by seeking to limit how much control companies have over them and their brand.
3. PROMOTIONAL APPEARANCES AND ADVERTISING
Endorsement contracts typically include the obligation of public appearances that highlights the importance of the physical representation of the company's brand.
“1. In each Year, Endorser shall be available at times and places reasonably convenient to Endorser and the Company, for up to [NUMBER] hours on each of (a) [NUMBER] days to make personal appearances on Company's behalf; (b) [NUMBER] days to produce media content and television commercials on Company's behalf; and (c) [NUMBER] days to pose for photographs and otherwise assist Company in the preparation of its advertising and/or promotional materials utilizing the Endorser Identification.
2. Company shall make all required travel arrangements for Endorser's appearances … and pay (or reimburse) Endorser for all reasonable expenses including airline tickets, hotels, meals,” etc.
This provision details public appearance obligations for the endorser. For example, athletes attend in-person events for sponsored companies where they meet fans, sign jerseys, and promote items. The parties to an endorsement contract negotiate terms such as the days and hours of availability for the endorser to partake in these activities. For example, LeBron James is required to make public appearances because his endorsement contract with Nike has a clause that requires him to make appearances. Additionally, when athletes make commercials, this is because they have a contract clause like this one.
4. MORALS CLAUSES
The morals clause typically grants the company the ability to suspend or terminate the endorsement contract in the event of scandalous, criminal, or publicly reprehensible behaviors of the endorser.
This clause is considered one of the more controversial provisions and demands serious negotiations in an endorsement contract. Morals clauses typically include a cure provision that allows for contract renegotiations. The artist Ye, previously known as Kanye West, has recently (Fall 2022) been under scrutiny due to his controversial views and behaviors toward the Jewish community. This has caused him to lose millions of dollars in endorsements recently as companies such as Gap, Adidas, Balenciaga, and Foot Locker have terminated their contracts with him. This is likely because those companies’ contracts with Ye contained a morals clause, which allowed the companies to protect themselves when the endorser’s values don’t align with the company’s values, as Nick explained to us:
Unlike lower-level athletes, high-profile athletes such as LeBron James may have the leverage to negotiate Morals Clauses that allow them to terminate their endorsement contracts with companies if the companies engage in problematic behavior or if their views do not align. Endorsement contracts may also include clauses permitting companies to terminate the contracts if an endorser commits an act that is reasonably deemed by the company to be derogatory towards the company or the products, or which may tend to injure the success of the company.
What Do Companies Hope to Gain When Sponsoring?
Sponsoring athletes and other public figures allows companies to expand their reach even if their products are inferior. Brand recognition allows people to identify and build trust with a brand. For example, when Drake wears a product and posts it online, people will be interested in purchasing the same item to signal to others that they are cool and trendy.
The Federal Trade Commission Endorsement Guides
The Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) is the federal agency responsible for both consumer protection and antitrust law. Its declared mission is to "protect the public from deceptive or unfair business practices and unfair methods of competition through law enforcement, advocacy, research, and education." (See:https://www.ftc.gov/about-ftc/mission.) The FTC will investigate and sue in connection with endorsements and other advertising under Section 5 of the FTC Act, which prohibits misleading advertising.
The FTC publishes Endorsement Guides that provide guidance to endorsers, celebrities, and influencers on how to comply with laws related to advertising and endorsements, including advertising through social media. The Endorsement Guides include many recommendations, including the following:
“The Guides require an endorser to fully disclose any material connection between themselves and the brand if that connection might materially affect the weight or the credibility of the endorsement.”
The endorser must use the product when giving a personal endorsement. Brands may be liable for false or unsubstantiated endorser statements.
If you receive free products or other perks with the expectation that you will promote or discuss the advertiser’s products in your blog, you must disclose that it is a paid promotion.
“An advertisement employing endorsements by one or more consumers about the performance of an advertised product or service will be interpreted as representing that the product or service is effective for the purpose depicted in the advertisement. Therefore, the advertiser must possess and rely upon adequate substantiation, including, when appropriate, competent and reliable scientific evidence, to support such claims made through endorsements in the same manner the advertiser would be required to do if it had made the representation directly, i.e., without using endorsements. Consumer endorsements themselves are not competent and reliable scientific evidence.” FTC Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising, 16 CFR Section 255.2(a).
When famous athletes are promoting products, they must disclose if the product is a paid partnership or not depending on if the majority of followers know the link between the athlete and the brands. For example, Virat Kohli has a relationship with Audi and MRF, but he does not have to disclose a paid partnership because it is public knowledge. However, he must disclose that the promotion is a paid partnership when he promotes other brands. See: https://www.instagram.com/reel/Clp-lIiALF-/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y= and https://www.instagram.com/reel/Clc62_igrpK/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
Finally, in our interview with Eli, we asked him about the business side of YouTube, how he monetizes his channel, and his tips and advice for those looking to start a YouTube channel.
References:
* - The listed number of Instagram followers is as of December 10, 2022.
https://www.thewrap.com/brands-that-dropped-kanye-west-adidas-gap/
https://blog.hollywoodbranded.com/the-top-10-highest-endorsed-athletes-and-their-brands
https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/ftcs-endorsement-guides-what-people-are-asking